Skip to main content

Zillow Listings Are Not Always What They Seem

Many homeowners rely on Zillow to price and list their homes. But recent data and legal developments show that this may not be the safest approach.

  • Inaccurate Estimates: Zillow’s "Zestimate" often overvalues properties by 5–15%, creating unrealistic expectations for sellers. Homes priced too high often sit weeks or months longer than the market average.  Source 

  • Days on Market (DOM) Impact: Mispriced listings increase stress and delay access to cash. The longer your home sits, the more uncertain your financial situation becomes. 

Zillow wants to dominate the real estate market, aiming for a monopoly on listings, but that doesn’t always serve homeowners well.

The Legal Storm Around Zillow

Zillow’s aggressive expansion and monopolistic practices have led to several major lawsuits:

  • FTC Antitrust Lawsuit: Zillow allegedly paid Redfin $100 million to suppress competition in the rental listing market, potentially inflating prices for advertisers and renters. Source

  • Class-Action Lawsuit: Zillow is accused of inflating costs for homebuyers through its referral program, leading to higher-than-expected fees.

  • CoStar Copyright Lawsuit: Zillow faces $1 billion in claims for allegedly using thousands of copyrighted real estate photos without permission.

  • Compass Lawsuit: Allegations that Zillow’s listing rules limit competition by requiring listings to appear on Zillow within 24 hours.

All reported by Real Estate News - Read more here 

Impact on Homeowners:

  • Potentially inflated home values

  • Listings taking longer to sell

  • Reduced transparency and control over the process  

 

The Numbers Don’t Lie

According to Sell2Rent’s research on homeowners:

  • Average Seller: 51 years old, household income ~$105K, mostly single-family homes

  • Financial Urgency: 90% of sellers report medium to high urgency for liquidity

  • Property Condition: 60% of homes require no repairs, meaning many could sell quickly if given the right process

  • Decision Drivers: Speed, transparency, and the ability to remain in their home are top priorities

This data shows that homeowners need a solution that reduces stress, avoids false pricing, and provides clarity, exactly what Zillow listings fail to deliver.

 

Sell2Rent: A Better Alternative

sell2rent_a_family_in_their_living_room_the_seem_happy_and_co_f306d344-c6ad-473d-b0c1-e1f90dbfc334_3

After reviewing the pitfalls of Zillow, it’s clear that homeowners need a smarter approach. Sell2Rent provides that solution.

  • Accurate, market-based offers: No inflated estimates or false expectations.

  • Fast access to equity: Avoid long DOM and sell your home quickly.

  • Stay in your home: Our sale-leaseback program lets you unlock cash while remaining in your property.

  • Transparent process: No hidden fees or surprises, just clear steps from start to finish.

Learn more about Sell2Rent and the process here.

For homeowners facing financial stress or wanting a simpler, more reliable way to sell their home, Sell2Rent offers transparency, speed, and control, everything Zillow fails to provide.

Danny
Post by Danny
Oct 2, 2025 4:03:40 PM

Comments